Dragaera

Sethra Lavode vs. Enchantress of Dzur Mountain

Wed Aug 14 01:39:54 PDT 2002

On Wed, Aug 14, 2002 at 03:57:11PM +0800, Andrew Bailey
<andrew at networkharmoni.com.au> wrote:                                          
>>Who's going to have trouble pronouncing it?  Not the
>>returning book buyer.   
>>They're going to know how to spell it as well.                               
>The sales clerk when being asked about new books, perhaps.                    
>Basically anything that helps Steve sell more books is a good
>thing:)         

Not when it reduces their quality.

Not that this is such a significant change, but "The
Enchantress of Dzur Mountain" is IMHO clearly the better title. 
"Sethra Lavode" is harder to pronounce and spell, even.
                                                                                
I mean, think about it... clueless reader sees one book with 
each title.  Clueless reader A has NO idea who or what Sethra
Lavode is, and ignores the book.  A does, however, know what
an "Enchantress" and "Mountain" are, and can make a reasonable
guess that it's a fantasy novel about an enchantress who lives in,
or comes from, a mountain.  "Dzur" works just fine taken as a
proper name, even unrecognized.
                                                                                
Clueful reader B, however, will recognize both titles, and buy
the book regardless of title.

Thus, I don't really see anything gained by the new
title.
                                                                                
Anyone have any real idea what the clue percentage of SF novel                  
buyers is?  That is, of a given novel, what percentage sell to                  
people with clue and what percentage sell to people who pick up                 
the cover, say "Oooh, shiny!", and fail their saving throw vs                   
marketing?
                    
-- 
Matthew Hunter (matthew at infodancer.org)
Homepage: http://matthew.infodancer.org/index.jsp
Public Key: http://matthew.infodancer.org/public_key.txt