Dragaera

Swords, and a tolerable acquaintance with their length

Fri Aug 23 18:24:37 PDT 2002

> Kat said:

> > That being said, I'm still not clear to what extent the crossbow (outlawed
> > at some point by... the Pope? not sure... because it was so effective

I'd just read "banned by the Church".

> > against heavy armor [so I have to ask here - was the crossbow really more
> > effective than the longbow because of its massive draw weights, or some

I think the crossbow is easier to train people to use, and at the heavy end
might be able to pack in more power, and from weaker people -- you pump lots
of energy into a spring, and can use a crank, even if you're not strong enough
to move stuff by brute muscle.  Longbows have a faster rate of fire, but
you're kind of training for life [insert paeans to the independent yeoman
class of England, with spare time] and all the female archers of fantasy are
kind of silly.  You need upper body strength to bend that thing.  I mean,
sure, some women, but having it be a female specialty (cf. Queens Susan and
Lucy of Narnia) doesn't work.

-xx- Damien X-)