Dragaera

Earthsea (was A question re: Begining Fantacy for Youth)

Mon Nov 25 08:35:28 PST 2002

> >>* Ursula K Le Guin's Earthsea trilogy (the first three books only)
> >I dunno... they're a little dry and slow-moving. Good, but maybe not great
> >as an introduction to fantasy.
>Umm... mileage definitely does vary.  *boggle*

It's the density of the prose, I think. I didn't find them to be an easy 
read at all. (I enjoyed the first two immensely, the third less so, but 
they all took effort.) I'd be personally a little wary of using them as a 
first intro to fantasy, although definitely throw them at him later.

>Tehanu destroys everything the initial trilogy worked so hard to
>build.  The recent stuff is somewhere in between.

Maybe I'm projecting bad memories of Tehanu onto the original three. 
(Haven't read anything past Tehanu yet; not entirely sure if I'm going to.)


----
The time for action is past-- now is the time for senseless bickering!
--Ashleigh Brilliant