Dragaera

LOTR and Christianity (apologies)

Tue Nov 26 20:29:35 PST 2002

On Tue, Nov 26, 2002 at 04:38:05PM -0600, David Rodemaker wrote:

> I will also say that I do not think that T. had the goal as L. in writing a
> specifically NT/Christian allegory, merely that his writings are rich in
> Christian mystic/mythic imagery.

But also Norse/Germanic imagery. 

And "Christian imagery" should be careful to distinguish between actual
Christ-related imagery, and stuff related to monotheism and angels which is
shared with Judaism (maybe?) and Islam and owes a lot to general mystic
interest in the Middle Ages.

For example, there's a comic right now, "Lucifer", with much the same
cosmology as Neil Gaiman's "Sandman".  God, angels, heaven, hell.  Christian,
right?

Only, there's no _Christ_.  Not a hint.  (At least not these days, I've heard
of one in some Swamp Thing.  But Gaiman implied Christ was just one of the
Great Stories, and Carey doesn't touch it at all.)  (Uh, whoops.  Okay,
Lucifer does mention the "triune godhead" at one point.  But that's it.)  And
heaven and hell don't work the way most real-world Christians would expect.

Actually that's true for other stuff, like _Good Omens_.  A lot of stuff seems
to use _Paradise Lost_ as its mythic background, while stopping before the
Messiah entered the scene.

-xx- Damien X-)