Dragaera

A question re: Beginning Fantasy for Youth

Thu Nov 28 23:39:27 PST 2002

"Casey Rousseau" wrote:

> Mmm!  See also, Umberto Eco.  Four walks in the Fictional Woods,
> Interpretation and Overinterpretation and other works.  He talsk about a
> dialectic between intentio auctoris and intentio lectoris producing
> intentio operis.  (Forgive me please if I misspelled those, but I think
> you gen get the gist.

The spellings are spot on, actually.

Ah, but it isn't a classic Hegelian dialectic unless the reader's intention
is the antithesis of the author's intention... Eco does distinguish between
what he calls "open texts", i.e.,  works of art that actively involve the
'addressee'  or reader in their production -- and "closed texts"  that try
to evoke a limited and predetermined response. In the case of the former,
says Eco, the author is consciously trying to evoke a different subjective
result with every reader and every performance.

Pretty interesting and provocative stuff, regardless of whether you agree
with him or not.

cheers,
Divya

----------
"The question of all questions for humanity, the problem which lies behind
all others and is more interesting than any of them is that of the
determination of man's place in Nature and his relation to the Cosmos.
Whence our race came, what sorts of limits are set to our power over Nature
and to Nature's power over us, to what goal we are striving, are the
problems which present themselves afresh, with undiminished interest, to
every human being born on earth." --T.H. Huxley