Dragaera

Holy War of Reply-To Munging

Gaertk at aol.com Gaertk at aol.com
Sat Nov 30 14:19:24 PST 2002

In a message dated 11/29/2002 10:16:41 PM Eastern Standard 
Time, "Davis, Iain E." <feaelin at kemenel.org> writes:

> ...perhaps I missed a key item here.  Is there a way (as 
> defined in the relevant RFCs) for a message header to 
> indicate that a) the message in question is a list message 
> and b) discriminate between the real sender of the message, 
> and the list-sender?  So that a "standard compliant" mail 
> client could provide a mechanism (button, key, menu option, 
> voice command, whatever interface you prefer) that you 
> could acurrately select your target (individual, the list, 
> both, etc.) with a single click/keypress/command?
>
> That would certainly change my viewpoint. :)

I'd like to point out that Usenet solved all these problems
decades ago, as well as several issues that haven't been 
mentioned here (spoiler protection, quoting styles[1], REAL
threading...).  Speaking just for myself, I would be 
overjoyed if this discussion were moved to a newsgroup 
somewhere.

Does anyone know what resources are neccessary for a 
non-propagating newsserver like sff.net has?  Or better yet,
what needs to be done to get Mr. Brust a newsgroup over there
(like Patrick and Teresa have[2])?


[1]  I have a really hard time following discussions when
people put new material at the top or use a really funky
quote style like those rows of asterisks.

[2] news://news.sff.net/sff.people.pnh-tnh


--KG