Dragaera

Religion - The Pragmatic Argument for Belief in God

Rick Castello rick at 404.978.org
Tue Dec 3 19:28:54 PST 2002

Damien Sullivan said:
> On Mon, Dec 02, 2002 at 08:01:43PM -0500, Rick Castello wrote:
>>
>>      I am, myself, an agnostic, but I've always found Paschal's Wager,
>
> Pascal's, in what I usually read.

     Both spellings pop up in a great number of philosophy texts
     I was required to read and purchase for coursework in Phil.
     of Religion.

>>        If you believe that God does not exist, and God *does* exist,
>> then you will go to Hell. (A very bad thing.)
>
> Unless God is a rationalist, and thinks all these faith-based religions
> are really dumb and silly, and only selects good skeptics for the
> afterlife.  By choosing to believe without evidence you make yourself
> uninteresting in God's eyes.  (A very bad thing.)

     This comment has value only in its feeble attempt at humor,
     as a serious response would have taken into account the far
     too numerous to cite examples in various works where God
     obviously gives a damn about faith.

> Or unless Odin, fattened by all the wars of Europe, has managed to
> become the supreme deity of the world, and feeds the believers to the
> Harpies, whom he recruited from the moribund Greek pantheon to help him
> out come Ragnarok.

     Would this constitute faith in the All-Father?  ;)

> Bet we could make more ocunterexamples...

     You could *make up* lots of things... but is that useful?

     -Rick