Dragaera

Favorite NON-fiction  

Tue Jan 28 12:07:41 PST 2003

>And yet nobody, least of all David Gerrold or Robert Heinlein, thought
>_The Trouble With Tribbles_ plagiarized _The Rolling Stones_.  Or for
>that matter the Hornblower books.  In literature, if you borrow from
>enough sources and rub off enough serial numbers, it really does stop
>being plagiarism.

On the other hand, Ellison kicked up major stinks over "Back to the Future" 
(which he thought too similar to _Time Enough for Love_) and Terminator 
(which he thought too similar to his own _Demon with a Glass Hand_).

Personally, I thought both comparisons ludicrous [1], but it goes to show 
that the difference between thematic simularity and plagarism are often a 
matter of personal perspective.

--

[1] The *only* similarities I see are that TEfL is a time travel story where 
the protagonist visits his own mother, and that DwaGH is a story about a 
soldier from the future.  Beyond that, IMO, all similarities end.  Marty, 
>from BttF did not, for instance, actually have sex with his mom.

_________________________________________________________________
STOP MORE SPAM with the new MSN 8 and get 2 months FREE*  
http://join.msn.com/?page=features/junkmail