I apologise if I offended anyone. I do agree with the 2 "big spoilers" you listed (Godslayer and the sexy Jhereg) -- but we just finished a big discussion about that particular information (Namely, _Issola_) in which said spoiler was tossed about without protection. This lead me to assume that spoiler protection was not needed for a book which is, chronologically in both our world and theirs, earlier. Where exactly do we draw the line? Is it "bad form" to discuss Khaavren's appearance in _Teckla_ with notes about the _Romances_ because some readers of _Teckla_ may not have read _TPG_ and suchly? I maintain this list is, for the most part, "reader beware" in its entirety. If I'm wrong let me know. - T PS, I meant my post to stimulate discussion about the gods, not about spoiler protection...sigh. ----- Original Message ----- From: Casey Rousseau <casey at trinityhartford.org> To: Dragaera <dragaera at dragaera.info> Sent: Wednesday, August 06, 2003 2:24 PM Subject: RE: _Orca_ spoiler in Timothy Nelson's post in thread RE: Phoenix and Gods snip > avoiding stating explicitly. Naming the other persona of the one character > that appears as another is one, and referring to Godslayer by the name used > at the end of _Issola_ is in my mind the other snip