Dragaera

Paresh and "Arylle"

Thu Aug 14 02:57:29 PDT 2003

For what it's worth, I find Paresh's account highly implausible, and the
identification with T/A even more so.  That P would have solitary
unfettered access for so long to a library, especially if that's
Tazendra's library (surely Khaavren would have overseen the disbursal of
the estate even if everybody else is dead), seems unlikely.  That a Lyorn
would (deign to) attack him with sorcery seems further unlikely.  That a
Lyorn would physically show up in person to find someone (especially
post-interregnum, when he could use the Orb to phone ahead, or have a
servant phone ahead) I consider absolutely impossible.  Ridiculous, in
fact. And almost impossible to reconcile with any other House but perhaps
the Dzur - which would make the rest of the story ludicrous. That P would
escape unpursued and unexecuted still more unlikely (I think the nobles
would restrict access to such power and go to some trouble to track him
down - say, call up all his chattels and have them grab any odd Tecklas
they see - or use some sorcerous tracking method.  Though presumably P
could teleport after a year's concentrated study - well, there's an arms
race in assumptions which I assert the superior sorcerer Arylle would
win.)

It's possible that Aerich doesn't make it out of the Viscountiad and
Arylle is not a Lyorn and that Paresh and Vlad are accurate in their
account and I'm entirely deluded, but I think this story is most likely
just evidence of SKZB's early thoughts about the Paarfi romances and
most consistently explained as P trying to impress a credulous weirded-out
Vlad with a well- (or actually in my view not at all well-)polished lie.



On Wed, 13 Aug 2003, Alexx S Kay wrote:

> > I don't see Aerich dying off--I am in the process of reading _Teckla_ and
> > Paresh, a Teckla, is recounting his history to Vlad--he mentions Aerich, or
> > at least, the Duke of Arylle, coming to the door and asking for his Master,
> > presumably about why he wasn't receiving his tribute/tithe whatever. (Cause
> > of a massive fire that killed everyone but Paresh).  It was interesting to
> > see how the character changes when it's not Paarfi recounting the history.
> > But then, Paresh is Dragaeran, and so the story he tells might well have
> > been before the Duke of Arylle is presumably killed in _Sethra_.
>
> Paresh's story doesn't actually bode well for our Aerich.  Quoting my
> timeline again:
>
> ??? PI
> [Miscellaneous events that aren't exactly dated, but are Post-Interregnum
> and Pre-Vlad.]
>
>   Paresh grows up in a Dzurlord's home (Tk 27).
>   At 60, Paresh gets land (Tk 28).
>   At 80, Paresh's loans are paid off (Tk 28).
>   At 81, Paresh's home burns down (Tk 28-29).  [This implies subtly that
> his master is Tazendra, who has some history of exploding experiments (FH
> 52, 434-435).  Her literary model, Porthos, was also noted for his
> extensive (if largely unread) library.]
>   Paresh spends "most of a year" learning sorcery (Tk 30).
>   Paresh fights Aerich's son(?) (Tk 31-32).  [Paresh was almost certainly
> born after the Interregnum, since sorcery figures highly in his biography,
> and he makes no mention of any interruption of it.  He battles "The Duke
> of Arylle", who is "about my age" (in Dragaaeran terms, quite a young man).
> We can infer that Aerich has either died or retired.  His literary model,
> Athos, died and left his estate to an adopted son in _The Man in the Iron
> Mask_.  The Duke refers to Paresh's master as "him", but this is probably
> a mistranslation of the genderless Dragaeran pronoun on Brust's part (it
> being unlikely that Aerich's heir would be either misinformed or rude).]
>
> Alexx
>
> Alexx Kay
> Opinions expressed are my own and not necessarily those of my employers
> alexx at world.std.com
> http://world.std.com/~alexx
> My commitment is to truth, not consistency.
>    [Seen on a Nancy Button, http://www.nancybuttons.com/]
>