Dragaera

Books on tape

Kenneth Gorelick pulmon at comcast.net
Fri Nov 21 17:34:57 PST 2003

I have a question about the "books on tape" experience. You noted that 
it is different from "words on paper". I have tried two different "on 
tape" experiences: Learning Mandarin and continuing medical education. 
The first was reasonably successful. I got halfway through the program 
before I got bored, but I learned pretty well, including accent and 
intonation (per my Mandarin-speaking friends). The second was a dismal 
failure. I listened to the 30 minute tape at least 20 times and still 
don't know much about the role of neuraminidase inhibitors in the 
treatment of influenza.

The main difference between the two is interaction. The language tapes 
required me to stop the tape and repeat, and to speak along with the 
tape. I was able to focus on the material and never got into an 
accident. The CME tape, on the other hand,  simply involved listening. 
Normally I learn well in talks. With this, however, I constantly lost 
my train of thought and my attention would wander from the tape to the 
road and back.

I suppose that I could learn from a tape if I listened to it in a room, 
along with visual aids, but in a car...never!

So how would I do with books on tape? How can anyone follow plot, 
characters, etc., when only a fraction of your consciousness is focused 
on the tape? When I read, I shut out the world and concentrate on the 
book. When I drive I sure as heck can't do that!!!

Any thoughts?

Thanks,

Ken