Dragaera

Brust interview

Bato001 at aol.com Bato001 at aol.com
Tue May 11 06:40:48 PDT 2004

In a message dated 05/11/2004 4:49:04 AM Eastern Standard Time, 
fides at kludgeco.com writes:
Philip Hart wrote:

>1) Can anyone expect copyright on broad plot ideas expressed in a public
>forum?
>  
>

IANAL - it depends how specific it is and it is up to the court to 
decide which is something you don't want. You cannot copyright a 
stereotype for example - 'the wisearse sidekick' or 'boy meets girl' but 
when stereotype meets specific you start getting fuzzy legal gray areas.

Where an idea for a story is expressed doesn't matter otherwise no 
writing whould be covered since you don't get much more of a publc forum 
than publishing something ;-)

>2) Wow, what a pain.
>  
>

The problem is that such things would have to go to court and could go 
either way even if you had the idea first which is quite hard to legally 
prove. And anything that has to go that far is loosing even if you win 
the case.

>While the above is interesting, I really hope that we find out in the
>fullness of time what the prescient list idea was.
>  
>

Ditto.

:-)

Fides
Only an idiot would publish their idea to a public forum and then cry when 
someone else 'stole' it. I believe that anyone on this list who writes 'it would 
be way cool if.......' would be honored that Steve himself was thinking along 
those lines. I also highly doubt that Steve really needs to steal ideas from 
us humble peasants. As he said in the interview(a loose paraphrase, allow me 
some leeway here)- someone on the list came up with a story line that he had 
been considering and now he is not sure if he will use it. He mentioned nothing 
about reading the list and then thinking along the posted story line. Methinks 
that there may be some out there who suppose too much.


John D. Barbato, OD