Dragaera

Warriors, peasants, and mortality

Mark A Mandel mam at theworld.com
Tue Oct 5 18:13:27 PDT 2004

On Tue, 5 Oct 2004, Scott Schultz wrote:

#Becoming pretty tangential to Brust, but Tolkein's elves didn't physically

Tolk<ie>n.

#age in the way that the other Free Peoples did. Rather, as the centuries
#flowed past they tended to grow weary in spirit, eventually to find mortal
#life (for lack of a better descriptor) a burden rather than a joy. Tolkein's
#elves and "gods" (Valar, Maya, et al...) were all about the strengh of their
#spirit. Creation and life were a drain on that spirit. The elves in Middle
#Earth were subject to this "spiritual aging" rather sooner than the various
#branches of the High Elves who had lived at one time or another in Valinor
#where the "spiritual batteries" of the Valar helped keep them "fresh". (Yes,
#I realize how fast and loose I'm playing with the mythology here.)

Interesting. I like this. IIRC, JRRT said, in response to a letter or Q,
that they were not immortal but longeval (literally, 'long-lived'), in
that they weren't immune to death but did not experience age as
debilitating, as we and all other multicellular creatures do.


-- Mark A. Mandel