Dragaera

Punishment

Tsarren tsarren
Thu Aug 18 00:29:34 PDT 2005

On Wed, Aug 17, 2005 at 02:19:06PM -0600, Howard Brazee wrote:
> John Klein wrote:
> 
> >So why would things that are the same merit different levels of
> >punishment? 
> 
> It depends on what purpose the punishment has.   If punishment is 
> designed to stop an infant from doing something dangerous, a quick slap 
> or yell does the job.   If punishment is designed to deter revolution, 
> maybe heads on a spike and no consecrated burial is necessary.   
> (Morganti blade death?).
> 
> Punishments are designed to deter, to protect the rest of us, and to 
> satisfy our lust for "justice".

Yes.  I was taught in sunday school long ago that all sins are the same in
the eyes of the Judeo-Christian God - steal a piece of candy, steal a car -
it's the same.  However, our society treats them differently with respect to
punishment.  Hence the differences - there are two paradigms, which sort of
overlap in the Bible because the religion *is* the culture/society in some
places.

Kat