The Question- Are Morganti weapons effective in the Halls of Judgement? I propose they are conditionally- when applied to non-divinities. Because: Morganti weapons destroy souls. Souls are extant in the paths of the dead. (re: Issola, Taltos, etc.) The only textev I can remember that may support this is that in Taltos (I may have the book inaccurate) Morrolan is fighting with the presumably dead Dragonlord (before Vlad mixes it up) and ""She (Morrolan's opponent) looked at it (Blackwand) apprehensively. "Don't worry, it does what I tell it to." says Morrolan."" This to me implies at least that Blackwand in particular could/would be effective in destroying a soul permanently while it is "unbodied"- that is, when the soul-destroying properties are active and come into contact with the soul-material-as-energy-field (Issola). I postulate that Blackwand is (for this question) a special case of Morganti weapon, in that its soul-destroying properties can be "turned off", either by the sentient blade itself, or by the will of Morrolan. I also postulate that the "people" in the Halls, and also specifically in the outlying areas, are the soul-material-as-energy-field, either temporarily embodied, or that actually the Halls (and environs) are a dimension where the soul-material is manifested as a body, while Vlad and Morrolan's bodies are .... hmmm.... either still exstant and are treated as soul-material, or possibly their physical forms are subsumed by their soul-material, or temporarily suppressed by their soul-material- because most physical bodies don't actually make it out of the shoreline area. This might have implications on the whole debate about why V (as Easterner) was allowed one Get Out of Hall Free pass. Or not. James Griffin Still Another Vlad faN Ps. Enjoy