Philip Hart <philiph at slac.stanford.edu> Sent by: dragaera-bounces at dragaera.info 05/16/06 08:49 AM To "'Dragaera List'" <dragaera at dragaera.info> cc Subject Re: Agyar (Agyar?/Sixth Sense Spoilers) (Was Re: Brokedown Palace) >And note the name of this list. I haven't read _Gypsy_ or _Cowboy Feng's_ >yet, and I've gotten stuck early in _F&N_ twice now, and I appreciate the >fact that I can read this list without inadvertently coming across the >Cliff's Notes versions of their plots. I don't really think our concept of what makes a spoiler is all that different. We've just been of a different opinion as to whether or not the specific /Agyar/ premise was, in fact, a spoiler or not. On reflection, I can certainly appreciate that information regarding non-Dragaera works needs much closer scrutiny than the Dragaera works (this being a Dragaera-centric list) than the other books (I've gotten bogged down in F&N myself at this point, have barely touched Cowboy Feng's, and don't even own a copy of S, M, & S, so I can certainly relate.) Majikjon And I still think there's maybe a need for a FAQ or something to help newbies (not just myself, but it certainly would have helped) avoid such missteps. Otherwise, new contributors will be discouraged from posting, for fear of breaking some unclear taboo. Just my $0.02.