Dragaera

OT: Subjectivity vs. Objectivity (was: bois...)

Thu Aug 15 19:16:14 PDT 2002

Mark A Mandel wrote:
> 
> Ah, you don't like imprecision? You must be very unhappy with English,
> which, unlike German, fails to force its speakers to distinguish a male
> friend (Freund) from a female one (Freundin) and an intimate "you" (du)
> from a polite one (Sie)... let alone Hebrew, which distinguishes male
> "you" (atah) from female "you" (at). --- Oh, but German *does* have a
> word that means just what the newer use of "hopefully" covers:
> hoeffentlich.
> 

I'm afraid I have to agree with Steve on this one -- shifts in language
which lead to loss of the possibility of nuanced expression are to be
deplored; but that isn't the same as wanting to import all the
distinctions of other languages simply to expand the language (FWIW, I
would think that Greek, with its very much greater flexibility, is an
even better counterexample than German).

_My_ bete noire, however, is not "hopefully", but the breakdown in the
distinction between "shall" and "will".

-- 
James Burbidge			jamesandmary.burbidge at sympatico.ca