Dragaera

Great Weapons (Issola Spoilers)

FelixEisen at aol.com FelixEisen at aol.com
Sun Nov 3 20:22:07 PST 2002

davids at kithrup.com writes:
>  ... he doesn't want to distress Lady Teldra by
>  making her do something so unnecessary & impolite.

I think you're overestimating -- or underestimating -- Vlad and Teldra.  I 
mean, consider their conversation throughout the book.  Clearly, Teldra 
respects Vlad, even considers him to be a sharp cookie.  Vlad knows, either 
through experience or instinct, what is appropriate at what times.  People 
keep thinking of Teldra and the Issola in general as getting all distressed 
over impoliteness.  I think that the generalized 'you' have it wrong on that 
count.  The Issola don't concern themselves with politeness, they concern 
themselves with what is -appropriate-.

Paraphrased, Vlad says, "Lady Teldra.  Was that polite??"  Teldra smiles and 
replies, "No, but it was appropriate."  As she points out, there are a lot of 
things that Vlad could do that, in various circumstances, are -appropriate-.  
To the guy on the road who says, 'Move aside, whiskers,' Vlad could bow and 
scrape, tell him to fuck off, bust his kneecaps, or stick a dagger in his 
left eye.  All of them can be appropriate actions -- certainly not all of 
them can be described as -polite-.

Consider the line from the Cycle: 'Issola strikes from courtly bow'.  
Striking, in whatever manner, isn't POLITE.  It can, however, be appropriate. 
 What is appropriate when a Dragonlord insults you, busts up your home, and 
takes your things?  Declaring war on him.  What about a Dzurlord?  
Challenging him.  How about a Jhereg?  Sending an assassin after him.  How 
about a Phoenix?  Hey, who knows, right now there's only Zerika.  Maybe you 
send her a bottle of wine, work that entire 'decay' angle, you know?  
Whatever an Issola does, it is supposed to be APPROPRIATE.  That isn't the 
same as polite.

Of all the Houses, the Issola and the Yendi may be the most dangerous, 
because you never see it coming.  But at least with the Yendi, you expect 
them to be devious; the Issola don't strike people that way, because they 
forget that the easiest way to seize a castle is to take it from within...


Knightmarshall Felix
Surnamed Eisen, or "Iron Felix"
Hand of Morr, The Order of Bones