Dragaera

The Great Debate....to DDB

Fri Nov 29 06:02:30 PST 2002

SKZB wrote:
[...]
> Let's not say everyone.  Let us speak of someone who
> says, "I believe.  I believe purely on faith."  Now,

> would you say that this person, on this subject, is 
> thinking?

Well, it is always difficult to get inside another
person's head.  From my own experience I would say
that even though I am convinced that a thing is true,
and even though I may be doing my best *not* to think
about whether it is true or false, I cannot reach the
state of "not thinking about" something important to
me.  The best I can do is "not thinking much about" or
"trying not to think about," although the latter
usually also means "thinking a lot about."

As matters of religious faith are usually considered
important, either (1) your speaker's subjective
experience is substantially different from mine in
this respect, or (2) your speaker continues to think
about subjects in which he or she has faith.  I prefer
the latter explanation, though I am not sure I could
defend that preference rigorously.

-- Greg

(As a side note, some writers on religion strike me as
thinking quite a lot about matters of religious faith.
 Some express doubts they continue to have, and
struggle with.  Others explore the rational
consequences of their faith in attempting to create an
internally consistent system of theology.  I would not
describe C.S. Lewis, to take an example brought up not
long ago, as "not thinking about" the subject of God.)

__________________________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail Plus - Powerful. Affordable. Sign up now.
http://mailplus.yahoo.com