Dragaera

The Great Debate....to DDB

Sun Dec 1 15:24:39 PST 2002

David S. said:

 >
Mm.  Problem-of-evil time in your model:  How do explain natural
disasters that kill and maim thousands?  How do you explain disease
(that doesn't just kill, but kills as slow torture)?  How about
genetic disease (that doesn't just kill slowly, but kills an innocent
child slowly)?
 >

You've got me!  My model does not explain evil well; bad things 
happening to good people or innocent people.  It's got everything else 
pretty well covered . . .

What was the science fiction story that had a man's wife dying on an 
alien planet of cancer?  His (alien) friend gave her the antidote to her 
painkiller so she could die in pain--it was an important issue in his 
religion that her death be a struggle.  The point of the story was that 
in this universe, our religious thought can explain death well, or 
suffering well, but not both.  In the alien's religious model, there was 
a good explanation for suffering, but a poor one for death.

The fact that I don't understand everything in our universe doesn't 
change my beliefs about God, though.

Mia