Dragaera

vishi-whatever

Talpianna at aol.com Talpianna at aol.com
Thu Nov 20 12:46:42 PST 2003

In a message dated 11/19/2003 10:34:56 PM US Mountain Standard Time, 
davids at kithrup.com writes:
I see no reference to any term even vaguely resembling "vishivit", and
looking under the topic of "Elves", nothing to indicate there is even
such a concept for elves. 

It doesn't sound like a term Tolkien would have coined for either
Sindarin or Quenya.  It sounds vaguely like something from perhaps
the Black Speech created by Sauron.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
<<<<<<<<<

    Tolkien based his Elvish languages on Finnish, whereas "vishivit" sounds 
more Slavic--could perhaps be from one of those obscure Central Asian dialects 
believed to be the basis of the Black Speech.  I have a friend in Moscow of 
Russian-Caucasian origin, and she swears the first time she heard the Black 
Speech in the first film, it sound like something her grandmother would say.  Her 
grandmother's dialect is so obscure I couldn't find it even in The Rosetta 
Project--possibly because she did not know the proper transliteration of the 
name into English.


                                tal