Dragaera

Mailing list vs. forum (was: warning to newbies)

Gaertk at aol.com Gaertk at aol.com
Tue Feb 10 17:12:40 PST 2004

Mark A Mandel <mam at theworld.com> writes:

> On Tue, 10 Feb 2004, Jason *Jaxel* Axelrod wrote:
>
># I personally think this would be best as a Usenet. 
># Newsgroups are great and I'm sure there would be no 
># problem with people using Outlook, Forte, Nutscrape or 
># anyone else's favorite NNTP.
>
> This list is moderated. Newsgroups are open to anyone and 
> can get a heavy load of spammers and trolls. I've been 
> using newsgroups since the Internet was first DARPANet 
> (early eighties), and I *really* value the civility and, 
> let me say, "trashlessness" of this list.

The moderation of this list is very loose though.  Has any
post ever been censored?

I am another who prefers USENET to email, and I've been 
looking at GMANE ( http://www.gmane.org/ ) which is a 
non-propogating newsserver gateway for mailing lists.  Note
that this simply allows people to use the list through a
newsreader; it wouldn't affect people who still want to use 
email.  Not sure if you'd get spam and trolls; I imagine most
of the miscreants don't know of its existence, and it appears
you have to register to access each list.

Could the Powers That Be take a look at it?


--KG