Dragaera

The Three Musketeers

Howard Brazee howard at brazee.net
Wed Jul 21 09:43:35 PDT 2004

Scott Schultz wrote:
>> Are there versions where Constance survives?
>>
>>
>
> The aforementioned Disney effort is one.

For the life of me I don't remember a Disney version.   Just as well.

> If I remember correctly, the
> Michael York version likewise had Constance alive at the end, but
> that one led into a sequel so they may have corrected it in The Four
> Musketeers. I wasn't ever inspired enough to actually watch the
> sequel so I don't really know if it was an extension of the first, an
> adaptation of 20 Years After or something else entirely.

This wonderful adaptation attempted to be true to the novel - so much so
that it could not be cut to movie length.   So they split it into two
movies.   The cast sued to be paid for two movies, but I don't remember the
result of that.

I like this version better than the Gene Kelley version even if his
acrobatics were fun to watch.

The typical movie is long enough for something like a 110 page novel.   I
just bought the DvD of _Master and Commander, Far side of the World_ and am
interested in seeing how successful it was.